Dess Dermondy blog home page
Dess Dermondy rock music
1. A human life isn’t just a body—it’s a point of view
Each person is a conscious perspective on the world. There’s only one “you” experiencing your thoughts, memories, relationships, plans.
Philosophers like Thomas Nagel emphasize that there is “something it is like” to be a person. Killing doesn’t just remove a body—it erases an entire subjective universe. That’s not replaceable. Even if someone else is similar, they’re not that same perspective.
So the weight comes from this:
killing = permanently ending a unique center of experience
2. It destroys an entire future, not just a present
A person isn’t just what they are right now—they’re also everything they could become.
Think about it this way:
- future relationships
- future ideas
- future happiness, struggles, growth
All of that disappears instantly.
That’s why some philosophers say killing is not just harm—it’s the maximum deprivation. It takes all remaining possibilities at once.
3. It breaks the “basic rule” that makes society possible
Imagine a world where killing didn’t matter.
You wouldn’t trust:
- strangers
- neighbors
- even close relationships
Philosophers like Thomas Hobbes argued that without a strong rule against killing, life collapses into fear and survival mode. You can’t build meaning, art, love, or even normal daily routines if your existence is constantly at risk.
So philosophically:
“don’t kill” is the foundation that allows everything else to exist
4. It treats a person as if they don’t matter
This is where Immanuel Kant comes in.
His idea is that people have dignity—not a price. You can’t measure or trade them like objects.
Killing someone says, in effect:
“your existence can be ended for some purpose or reason.”
That’s why it’s seen as crossing a fundamental moral line—it reduces a person from a someone to a thing.
5. It creates irreversible moral weight
Most wrong actions can, at least in theory, be repaired:
- you can return stolen money
- apologize for harm
- rebuild trust (sometimes)
But death is final.
That permanence gives killing a different philosophical status:
it’s an action that closes off all correction, growth, or reconciliation forever
6. Even if meaning is uncertain, life becomes more precious
Some philosophers like Albert Camus argue that the universe might not have built-in meaning.
But instead of making life meaningless, that actually makes each life more significant:
- it’s rare
- fragile
- self-created
So ending a life isn’t just stopping biology—it’s ending a rare instance of meaning being created in a silent universe.
Putting it all together
Killing matters so much because it combines multiple extremes at once:
- It erases a unique conscious experience
- It eliminates an entire future
- It undermines the trust that holds society together
- It violates the idea that people have inherent worth
- And it cannot be undone
That’s why, across almost every philosophy and culture, it ends up at the top of “things that matter.”
